-23.avif)
Leadership Consultancy for Tech Scale-Ups: Pick One That Moves the Needle
How to Hire a Leadership Consultancy: A Founder's Buyer's Guide
Most founders hire a leadership consultancy the same way they hire a plumber. Pipe's leaking. Call someone. Pay the bill. Hope it stops.
Then six months later the same VP is still ducking the same conversation, the same team is still missing the same numbers, and the consultant is on a beach in Tulum.
A real leadership consultancy doesn't patch leaks. It rebuilds the plumbing. And if you can't tell the difference at the sales call, you're already paying for the wrong one.
The Problem: Most Scale-Ups Buy the Wrong Thing
The pattern repeats at almost every Series B I work with.
The CEO knows leadership is the bottleneck. Engineering is fine. Sales is fine. Product is fine. But the executive team can't agree on a roadmap. The VP of Engineering is fighting the VP of Sales. The Chief of Staff is acting like a therapist. Headcount doubled. Trust did not.
So the CEO Googles "leadership consultancy" and books three calls. One sends a deck full of frameworks nobody will use. One offers a 360 assessment and a coaching package. One promises a two-day offsite that will "align the team."
All three sell motion. None of them sell change.
The cost of poor leadership at a 200-person scale-up isn't a bad hire. It's six months of velocity bleeding out the side of the company. And consultants who don't measure that don't get paid to fix it. They get paid to be there.
The Insight: A Leadership Consultancy Is a Diagnostic Practice, Not a Vendor
Think of it like a doctor.
A bad doctor sells you the procedure they happen to do. A good doctor diagnoses what's actually broken and refers you out if it's not in their wheelhouse. The first one is selling their service. The second one is selling your outcome.
A real leadership consultancy works the same way. They start with diagnosis. What level is the team operating at? Where's the dysfunction? Is it a trust problem, a clarity problem, or an accountability problem? Then they prescribe.
That's what the Six Levels framework is for. We don't show up with a "leadership program" and try to jam it down. We assess where each team sits on the six levels of high-performing teams and build the work from there. Some teams need to start at psychological safety because they don't have it. Some teams have it and need to fix their commitment problem. Same logo, totally different intervention.
Amy Edmondson at Harvard has spent two decades showing this. Teams that feel safe to speak up outperform teams that don't, by a measurable margin. Google's Project Aristotle landed on the same answer after studying 180 of their own teams. Psychological safety is the single biggest predictor of team performance. Not skill. Not experience. Not even IQ.
So when a leadership consultant walks in with a generic "leadership development" deck and never asks about safety, never asks about how decisions actually get made, never asks who can disagree with the CEO in a room, they're not consulting. They're catering.
The Three Things a Real Leadership Consultancy Does
Strip away the brochure language. There are really only three jobs.
1. Diagnose the actual bottleneck. Where on the org chart is decision velocity dying? Who can't have a hard conversation? Which VP is hoarding context? A good consultancy maps this in the first two weeks. A bad one assumes.
2. Build a system, not a session. A workshop is a moment. A system is a cadence. If the consultancy's deliverable is "we ran an offsite," ask them what changes on Monday. If the answer is vague, you bought a retreat.
3. Stay long enough for it to stick. Phillippa Lally's research at University College London found it takes 66 days on average for a new behaviour to become automatic, and for more demanding behaviour changes (like exercise habits) the median climbed to 91 days. Real behaviour change at the executive level takes months of repetition and reinforcement, not a session. If a consultancy disappears after the keynote, they sold theatre. The ones that work are the ones that come back and pressure-test the change six weeks in.
That last one is where most consulting engagements quietly fail. The contract ends at the workshop. The behaviour reverts within a quarter. Nobody calls it a failure because nobody measured anything.
The Buyer's Trap: Brand Names That Don't Fit Scale-Ups
There's a tier of leadership consulting firms that look very impressive on a McKinsey alum's LinkedIn. They've worked with Boeing. They've worked with Pfizer. They write thoughtful articles about change at scale.
They are mostly wrong for a 100-person Series B.
Enterprise consultancies are built for matrix orgs with HR business partners, learning departments, and three-year change initiatives. You don't have those. You have a head of people who got promoted from recruiting nine months ago and a CEO who runs every Tuesday standup. The interventions that work at Pfizer will get laughed out of your all-hands.
What works for a tech scale-up looks more like a founder bottleneck audit, a tight 6-week leadership sprint, and a small set of behavioural rituals the executive team can actually hold. Not a 12-month "leadership development journey." Nobody at your stage has 12 months to journey.
Practical Application: How to Hire the Right One
Stop watching the deck. Start watching the questions.
When you get on a sales call with a leadership consultancy, the first 20 minutes will tell you almost everything. What to listen for:
Then ask them this exact question: "What does success look like in 90 days, and how will we both know we hit it?"
If they can't answer that with specifics, meeting decisions per week, retention numbers, a measurable shift in a team performance benchmark, they're not selling outcomes. They're selling hours.
Questions to Ask Every Leadership Consultancy
Take this list to your next sales call. Don't paraphrase. Read them word for word and watch how they squirm or settle in.
- What's the smallest engagement you'd recommend for a team my size?
- How do you measure whether the work actually worked?
- Who's the right buyer at our stage, me, my head of people, or my COO?
- What's the failure mode you see most often, and how do you catch it early?
- Tell me about a client where you fired yourself because the work was done.
That last one is the tell. A leadership consultancy that's never fired itself either doesn't know what done looks like, or doesn't want to. Both are bad. You want the ones who measure their own success by how fast they become unnecessary.
What You Should Expect to Pay (And Why It Varies)
This is where most CEO blog posts get evasive. So let me be specific without quoting anchor numbers.
The math is rarely the problem. The wrong consultant is.
The Wrong Question Most Founders Ask
Most founders ask, "How do I find a great leadership consultancy?"
That's the wrong question.
The right question is: "What problem am I actually trying to fix, and is leadership consulting the right tool?"
Sometimes it isn't. Sometimes you need a recruiter, not a consultant. Sometimes you need to fire one person, not coach four. Sometimes the team is fine and the CEO is the bottleneck. Real consultancies will tell you that on the diagnostic call. Bad ones will sell you a year of work anyway.
If you're not sure where to start, our facilitators usually do a free 30-minute scoping call. Not a sales call, a "what's actually broken" call. You can book one here and we'll either help you, refer you, or tell you it's not a leadership problem.
Conclusion
A leadership consultancy is a tool, not a deliverable. The wrong one sells you a workshop and disappears. The right one diagnoses the bottleneck, builds a system around it, and stays long enough for it to stick.
The plumbers keep showing up because nobody fixed the plumbing. Find the consultancy that rebuilds it.
Want to see the framework we use to diagnose where your team is actually stuck? Download the free Six Levels of High-Performing Teams eBook, it's the same diagnostic we run with paying clients. Get the Six Levels eBook
Frequently Asked Questions:
Now that you have mastered how to manage conflict - what is your plan of action for making an impact with your team?
Now that you have mastered how to create an environment of empowerment via the 3-P's - what is your plan of action for making an impact with your team?
Developing Your Communication, Empathy and Emotional Intelligence skills is start. What is your plan of action for implementing your learnings within your your team?
Now that you understand the differences in these titles - what is your plan of action for what you learned?
Assessing your team's behaviors is a start - but do you have a plan of action for the results?
Now that you have mastered the art of decision making - what is your plan of action for making an impact with your team?
.png)
A DISC Behaviour Assessment is the best way to understand your team's personalities.
Each DISC Assessment includes a Self Assessment and DISC Style evaluation worksheet
.webp)
