I watched a founder lose an entire quarter once.

Not to a market shift. Not to a bad hire. To a spreadsheet full of OKRs that nobody looked at after the first week.

He'd read Measure What Matters over a weekend, came into Monday's standup fired up, and told his team of twenty-two they were switching to OKRs. By Wednesday, he had a colour-coded Google Sheet with company OKRs, team OKRs, and individual key results for every person. It was a masterpiece of goal-setting ambition. By Friday, half the team was confused. By the end of the month, the whole thing was quietly abandoned.

The irony is: the OKR framework actually works. Google used OKRs to scale from 40 employees to over 100,000. Intel used them to dominate semiconductor manufacturing. The methodology has been stress-tested by some of the most successful companies in history. But there's a gap between knowing what OKRs are and actually implementing OKRs in a way that sticks. And most startups fall right into it.

I've helped dozens of startups through their OKR journey, and the pattern is always the same. It's rarely the framework that fails. It's the rollout.

Here are the six most common OKR mistakes I see, and what to do instead.

‍

Mistake 1: Too Many OKRs (The Goal Buffet Problem)

The most common mistake with OKR adoption is treating it like a to-do list.

You sit down with your leadership team, and everyone has ideas. Sales wants four objectives. Product wants three. Marketing wants five. And because you don't want to leave anyone out, you end up with twelve company OKRs and forty key results across the org.

That's not strategic prioritization. That's a buffet.

The whole point of using OKRs is to force hard choices about what matters most. If everything is a priority, nothing is. John Doerr, who brought the framework to Google from Intel, was clear about this: three to five objectives per cycle, each with two to five KRs. That's it. When you have too many OKRs, you don't get focus. You get fragmentation. Team members can't tell you what the company's top priority is because there are fourteen things competing for that spot.

Here's what I tell every founder starting their first OKR cycle: if you can't recite your top three objectives from memory, you have too many. Full stop.

The discipline is in what you say no to.

‍

Mistake 2: Writing Key Results That Are Actually Initiatives

This one trips up smart people constantly. You set an objective like "Build a world-class onboarding experience." Great. Your key results are: "Redesign the onboarding email sequence," "Create a welcome video," and "Set up a Slack channel for new hires."

Those aren't key results. Those are tasks. Initiatives. A to-do list dressed up in OKR clothing.

A key result answers the question: How will we know we succeeded? It needs a number. A metric. Something you can measure. "Increase new user activation rate from 34% to 55%" is a key result. "Redesign the onboarding email sequence" is a task that might help you get there.

The distinction matters because when you conflate KRs with initiatives, you lose what makes OKRs powerful: the data-driven feedback loop. You can complete every task on your list and still not move the needle. That's a terrible feeling at the end of a quarter, and it happens more often than people admit on LinkedIn.

Separate your initiatives from your key results. The initiatives are the work. The KRs are how you know the work is working.

‍

Mistake 3: Setting OKRs Purely Top-Down

Here's a pattern I see among startups with 20 to 100 people. The CEO goes on a retreat, comes back with a business strategy and a set of company OKRs, then cascades them down through the org. Each team gets their marching orders. Each individual gets told what their goals are.

On paper, it appears aligned. In practice, it creates silos and kills ownership.

When goal-setting is purely top-down, you miss two things. First, the people closest to the work often have the best insight into what's realistic and what metrics actually matter. Your frontline team knows things about customer behaviour that your dashboards don't capture yet. Second, research on motivation consistently shows that people are more committed to goals they helped create. It's basic psychology. If I set a goal for you, it's my goal. If we set it together, it's ours.

The best OKR process I've seen in startups works in both directions. Leadership sets the top two or three strategic priorities for the quarter. Then teams propose their own objectives and key results that support those priorities. The conversation that happens in between is where the real alignment lives. Not in a spreadsheet. In the dialogue.

This is what we call participative design at Unicorn Labs. When people help shape the goals, they own them. And when they own them, you don't have to chase them down for updates.

‍

Mistake 4: Skipping Check-Ins

You launch your OKRs at the start of Q1. Everyone's excited. The dashboards are set up, the OKR software is configured, and there's a company-wide Slack channel dedicated to tracking progress.

Then three weeks go by, and nobody checks in.

This is the silent killer of every OKR implementation I've witnessed fail. The OKR cycle isn't a "set it and forget it" system. It's a living rhythm. Without regular check-ins, your OKRs become a quarterly performance review that nobody cares about until the last two weeks of the quarter, when everyone scrambles to update their numbers.

Monthly check-ins are the heartbeat of successful OKRs. This is a real-time pulse where each team member reports on their KRs, flags blockers, and asks for help. I've seen teams do this in a Monday standup, in a shared Google Doc, or in a quick async Loom video. The format matters less than the consistency.

What this does is create something far more important than accountability. It creates visibility. When everyone can see how the team is tracking, priorities become self-correcting. People notice when a key result is stalling and naturally shift resources. That's the kind of teamwork that turns a goal on a wall into a goal that actually gets hit.

My biggest thing, and I say this to every team I work with: monthly scorecards are the most powerful thing we've initiated in our own team and in other teams. When your people start reporting on their metrics every single week, they start to own them. It stops feeling like your goal and starts feeling like theirs.

‍

Mistake 5: Using OKRs as a Performance Management Weapon

This mistake is subtle and destructive.

A founder decides that OKR scores will be tied directly to performance reviews, bonuses, or promotions. On the surface, it sounds logical. You want people to take their goals seriously, so you attach consequences. But the moment you do this, you corrupt the entire system.

When key results are tied to compensation, people stop setting stretch goals. Why aim for 70% completion of something ambitious when you can aim for 100% of something safe? You don't get bold goal-setting. You get sandbagging. And your best people, the ones with the most potential, start gaming the system instead of pushing the company forward.

Google understood this early. Their OKR methodology explicitly separates OKRs from compensation decisions. The target score isn't 1.0. It's 0.6 to 0.7. That means if you're hitting every single one of your key results, you're not setting them aggressively enough.

Keep OKRs and performance reviews in separate conversations. OKRs are a learning tool, a prioritization tool, and a strategic alignment tool. The moment they become a punishment or reward mechanism, you lose the psychological safety required for honest reporting. Without honest reporting, your data-driven approach becomes fiction.

‍

Mistake 6: Trying to Boil the Ocean in Your First OKR Cycle

The last common OKR mistake is the most forgivable, and the most expensive.

A startup decides to implement OKRs across the entire company in a single rollout. Every department. Every team. Every individual. Day one. Full rollout.

It almost never works.

OKR adoption is a skill, not a switch. Your team members need to learn how to write good objectives. They need to learn the difference between a key result and an initiative. They need to develop the muscle of weekly review. And that takes practice. Expecting a 50-person company to master this in a single quarter is like expecting someone to run a marathon the day after they buy running shoes.

The step-by-step approach works better. Start with one team. Maybe the leadership team, maybe a product squad that's already high-functioning and hungry for more structure. Run a single OKR cycle with that pilot group. Let them make the mistakes, learn the rhythm, and build the internal know-how. Then expand. Let the pilot team become your coaches for the next wave of teams.

This is how the most successful startups I've worked with have done it. Not through a company-wide memo. Through a small, focused experiment that builds credibility before it scales.

‍

The Real Insight About OKRs Nobody Talks About

Here's what I've come to believe after years of watching startups succeed and fail at this.

The benefits of OKRs aren't really about the goals themselves. They're about the conversations the goals force you to have. When you sit down with your team to set OKRs, you're forced to answer: What are our strategic goals this quarter? What does success actually look like? How will we measure it? Who owns what?

Most startups have never had those conversations clearly. They've got them scattered across Notion docs, Slack threads, and the CEO's head. The OKR framework forces that clarity into the open. It takes the fog of day-to-day execution and gives it shape.

And the monthly check-ins? Those force a different kind of conversation: What's working? What's stalled? Where do we need help? Those are the conversations that high-performing teams have every week, whether they use OKRs or not.

So if you're early in your OKR journey, don't obsess over perfect KPIs or the right OKR software. Obsess over the quality of the conversations. Start small. Be honest about what you don't know. And trust that the framework will teach you what your team actually needs, if you let it.

The goal was never the spreadsheet. The goal was always the team.

Want to go deeper? The Unicorn Labs Leadership Vault is packed with free resources to help you optimize your leadership, including an OKR guide to help you set, score, and review time-bound objectives with your team. It's the streamline we wish every startup founder had on day one.

‍

FAQs: