CASE STUDY
HIROC
How a VP nearly 25 years into his career used one-on-one coaching to go from good to great.
A conversation with:
Gareth Lewis
Vice President Claims
CASE STUDY

HIROC

How a VP nearly 25 years into his career used one-on-one coaching to go from good to great.
A conversation with:
Gareth Lewis
Vice President Claims
Gareth Lewis
Vice President Claims
Project History

HIROC exists because of a crisis in Ontario healthcare in the mid-1980s. Liability premiums for hospitals rose sharply, and one major commercial insurer stopped covering them altogether. For a publicly funded hospital, that is not a budgeting problem. A hospital cannot operate without insurance.

Two commissioned reports looked at the same question: could hospitals insure themselves instead? Both recommended the same answer. Form a reciprocal.

1987Year HIROC was created as a reciprocal
53Healthcare organizations at founding
~95%Of healthcare insured outside Quebec and British Columbia
24Years Gareth has been at HIROC

A reciprocal is an insurance arrangement where the members are all in the same business and agree to share each other's losses. In practice, it means the customers are also the owners. HIROC was created on that model in 1987, starting with 53 healthcare organizations under the name HIRO, the Hospital Insurance Reciprocal of Ontario.

Today it insures roughly 95% of healthcare in the country outside Quebec and British Columbia, which run their own programs. It is the largest reciprocal in Canada, and it went on to launch the Canadian Association of Insurance Reciprocals to advocate for the model and help smaller, newer reciprocals find their footing.

HIROC reception desk with the HIROC sign on the wall

The ownership structure is the whole point. There is no daylight between what is good for the company and what is good for the client.

“It's not like we've got to look after the shareholders. The shareholders are the subscribers. So we're an honest broker, always trying to act in their interests.”

Gareth Lewis, HIROC

Gareth Lewis was employee number 41. He joined as a junior file examiner before he finished university, mostly because he needed a job and didn't entirely know what a file examiner was. This September marks 24 years. He is now a Vice President on a senior leadership team of six.

02Why & What Changed

What Triggered Working with Unicorn Labs

01A senior leader looking for a next step after formal education had run its course
02An organizational commitment to funding leadership development
03Work volume growing faster than the systems built to carry it
04Momentum from the department already participating in Unicorn Labs workshops

Significant Outcomes

01A six-month pilot became an open-ended engagement. Gareth asked to continue three separate times, and HIROC funded it each time, taking a trial past the twelve-month mark and counting
02Nonviolent communication moved from Gareth's own practice to the wider department, taught by him at a company-wide session he wasn't leading
03A shared leadership vocabulary across the department after the director and all leads completed the program, cutting the time spent establishing what people mean before discussing what they think
04A repeat referral source. Gareth has recommended Unicorn Labs to peers unprompted and keeps his coach's cards on his desk for the conversations he knows are coming.
03The Leader

Nobody Was Struggling

This is the part worth being clear about, because it shaped everything that followed.

Gareth was not in trouble. He had completed an Executive MBA at Queen's, which he describes as transformational, and plenty of formal leadership training before that. His department already had a culture he was proud of and had helped build. HIROC invests seriously in developing its people, and Gareth had taken advantage of that for years. His own summary of what he was after: good to great.

HIROC Insurance Services staff at HIROC's Annual Appreciation Dinner

He wanted something courses had stopped providing.

“I'm fine with courses. Courses I'm good at; I was always a strong student. It's more so executive coaching, just having someone I can talk to about this, about that. Not that I think I was struggling, but there's always an opportunity to be better.”

Gareth Lewis, HIROC

Real pressures drove the interest. Work volume at HIROC has been growing at a pace Gareth describes as almost unsustainable, which is a good problem right up until the moment you fail to deliver on it. He had a newly promoted director finding her feet in the role. And after a long stretch in the VP seat, he had the sense of having gotten himself about as far as he could get on his own steam.

“I don't think stuck was the word. I was just sort of lagging.”

Gareth LewisHIROC
04The Match

Choosing His Own Coach

HIROC's CEO had suggestions. Several good ones. Gareth turned them all down.

“I thought, thank you very much, but with respect, I'd kind of like to choose my own. And I'd prefer that they not be somebody that you know. It's really something for me.”

Gareth Lewis, HIROC

That instinct turned out to matter. The value of the coaching, in Gareth's telling, depended heavily on it being genuinely separate from his work life, a space where he could think out loud without calculating who might hear about it later.

By that point the department was already working with Unicorn Labs on other things, and Gareth had formed a view.

“It's very slick, and not just show and no go. There's substance there. Real substance and content.”

Gareth LewisHIROC

Twenty-four years at one organization means a lot of vendors, a lot of consultants, a lot of team-building sessions. Gareth's takeaway was blunt: they are not all created equal, and Unicorn Labs developing its own content, grounded in its own research, was what set it apart.

So he asked Fahd directly whether he could find a coach through Unicorn Labs. Fahd took time to think about the match rather than assigning the first available name, and came back with Jordan.

05The Coaching

Not Therapy, and Not a Course

Gareth had never worked with a coach before, and his first question was the honest one: what actually is this?

“One, what is this? Like, what is coaching? And Jordan was very upfront and clear about how it was going to work. First, an intake call and a chemistry call to see if we even get along, because it's not going to work if we don't get along.”

Gareth Lewis, HIROC

They got along. The framing Jordan offered stuck with him: coaching has an objective, a point A and a point B, and the job is getting unstuck. Not talking in circles. Not processing feelings for their own sake.

Two things made it work faster than Gareth expected.

The first was fit. Jordan is a lawyer, and Gareth works closely with lawyers every day. Their industry backgrounds overlap enough that Gareth never had to explain his world from scratch. He also has a habit of tracing words back to their roots, which for someone who spends his days in a profession built on precise language was less a quirk than a shared dialect.

The second was lived experience. Gareth is careful to say there is nothing wrong with a coach who draws on formal training. But he found the stories landed differently.

“Jordan's also drawing on lived experience. Like, oh, I had this one thing. I find stories and examples just so compelling.”

Gareth Lewis, HIROC

He also names something most people would not admit about group learning: in any room, some people are reading the words without the words hitting. That is fine, and it is normal. It is also unavoidable at scale. One-on-one, it stopped being a problem.

“I found with Jordan, everything, I got it. And if I didn't get it, I'd ask him. Wait, can you explain that to me again? Show me that. Very patient.”

Gareth Lewis, HIROC
06The Work

What They Actually Worked On

The sessions ran biweekly, and Gareth says something always came up in the gap.

Three threads came back repeatedly.

01

Relationships at senior levels. Everything is easy when everyone is getting along. When there is friction between colleagues, or between a leader and the person they report to, it is considerably less easy, and it is rarely a business problem in any clean sense. Finding ways to make those working relationships more efficient and pleasant made a bigger difference than Gareth expected.

02

Supporting a newly promoted leader. One of Gareth's directors was new to the role and finding it hard, which is exactly what a new role is supposed to feel like and also exactly when people quietly decide they made a mistake taking it.

“How do we get them to not regret taking the role? How do I properly support them and help them without doing the job for them, in a way that will make them want to keep going?”

Gareth Lewis, HIROC
03

Volume. Not just managing his own load, but protecting a team facing demands that keep climbing. Growth is the good problem. Failing to deliver on it is the catastrophic one.

Sometimes the answer, once he heard it, seemed obvious. Sometimes it was an approach he says he would never have arrived at alone. Either way, he left with something.

“I've never, not walked away with something concrete, something meaningful, actionable.”

Gareth LewisHIROC

Jordan tracked it all. Notes from the last session, follow-up on what Gareth said he would try, a check-in on the big Thursday meeting he had mentioned in passing. When Gareth hedged or skirted a topic, Jordan noticed and said so, without making it a confrontation.

“He's a good digger. He'd be like, hold on, you said a funny thing there. You seem to not want to talk about that. Is there more there?”

Gareth Lewis, HIROC
07The Tools

The Tools That Stuck

Nonviolent communication

Gareth had brushed up against nonviolent communication in the Unicorn Labs workshops, then went considerably deeper on it with Jordan, returning to it across several sessions. It changed how he approaches communication, particularly outside his own team, where the familiarity that smooths things over internally does not exist, and a badly structured message can create a problem out of nothing.

Then it left his office. At a recent department-wide business writing session run by someone else, Gareth jumped in to explain the model to the room, because he had found it useful enough that not sharing it seemed wasteful.

That is the part worth noticing. One person's coaching became a tool his colleagues now have.

The Eisenhower Matrix

The Eisenhower Matrix went the other direction, inward. He had never encountered it before. Now he draws the box constantly.

“It's a simple enough concept that you could explain it to somebody else. But I find it really helpful just having it inside my head. It's in that quadrant; we're not going to deal with this right now.”

Gareth Lewis, HIROC

Most of a leader's day, as he describes it, is triage and delegation. What is this, and who is best placed to handle it. Getting that wrong, or spending too long debating it, is what stalls a team. A problem that would once have cost him a headache now costs him a square drawn in the margin of a notebook.

08The Department

A Department Speaking the Same Language

Gareth was not the only one at HIROC working with Unicorn Labs. His director and all of his leads went through the program as well, four people in the department in total.

The effect he points to is not a dramatic culture change. HIROC's culture was already strong, and he has spent two decades helping build it. What shifted was precision.

HIROC team members at a HIROC event

“Even just terminology. Team 1 vs. Team 2, certain things we're able to talk about. Everybody knows it. A stronger baseline understanding for all.”

Gareth Lewis, HIROC

A shared vocabulary means less time spent establishing what you mean before you can discuss what you think. Gareth describes the department as more efficient and more effective as a result.

09The Shift

What Changed: The Confidence to Decide

Ask Gareth what changed in him and he starts by refusing to overstate it. Then he lands on the word.

Confidence. Not the loud kind.

“There's an irony where the smartest of us are so full of self-doubt and the dumbest of us are always so cocksure. I'm not saying I'm not aware of it. I'm just more comfortable with how I arrived at whatever decision it was.”

Gareth Lewis, HIROC

Part of that is having a sounding board. Part of it is the toolkit. He compares it to the MBA, where hitting the edge of what he knew meant enrolling in something and waiting. Now he brings the gap to a biweekly call and usually leaves with an answer, or with Jordan going to find one.

The original engagement was scoped at six months. It has run past twelve, extended each time Gareth asked HIROC to keep it going, which the organization has consistently supported.

“It's such a bonus, having that person there who you know is in your corner, and who has the training and the knowledge to be like, oh, try this, it should work.”

Gareth Lewis, HIROC

He describes it as the cartoon character on your shoulder, the one saying keep going, say that, you're doing the right thing.

10The Advocate

Resilience, Redefined

Gareth has recommended Unicorn Labs to a number of people, and keeps a stack of Jordan's cards on his desk for when it comes up. He is careful about how he frames the pitch.

“I'm not saying you need the help. I'm saying it'll just take you further. It's not a deficiency. It's quite the opposite.”

Gareth Lewis, HIROC

That framing came into focus for him through something HIROC's CEO said recently about resilience, a word Gareth had always understood to mean toughing it out.

“She said no, resilience isn't just being tough and dealing with it. Resilience is knowing when to put your hand up and say I could do with some help, and getting that help. Proud people have a hard time with that.”

Gareth Lewis, HIROC

Twenty-four years in, having built a career at one organization from junior file examiner to the executive team, Gareth had every reason to conclude he had this figured out. He put his hand up instead.

“I had never had a coach before, and I am converted. This is how you do it.”

Gareth LewisHIROC
leadership training to elevate your team’s performance today.
Join the 50,000+ people that have been impacted by one of my programs.
Gareth Lewis
Vice President Claims