Management Styles: The 6 Your Scale-Up Managers Need (and When to Use Each)
Your best engineer became a manager eight months ago. She manages the way she codes: fast, exacting, allergic to excuses. Half her team is thriving. The other half is interviewing elsewhere. Is that a talent problem or a style problem?
Most of the time, it’s style. Daniel Goleman’s research names six management styles: commanding, visionary, affiliative, democratic, pacesetting and coaching. No single style wins. The leaders with the best team climate and results had mastered four or more and switched between them as the situation changed. For a scale-up, that means visionary as the default and coaching as the growth engine, with commanding and pacesetting saved for emergencies.
The research behind it is Goleman’s 2000 HBR article, “Leadership That Gets Results”, built on data from 3,871 executives. It found that each style has a distinct effect on team climate, meaning how it feels to work on the team: its flexibility, sense of responsibility, standards, rewards, clarity and commitment. Climate, in turn, accounted for nearly a third of business results. How a manager shows up shapes the room, and the room shapes the numbers.
So before you roll out new manager training at a scale-up, check two things for each manager. Do they have more than one style? And do they know when to switch?
Why Do Scale-Up Managers Get Stuck in One Style?
At 20 people, the founder’s style is the management style. At 80, you have a dozen managers, and most of them got the job because they were great at the work. Few were trained to manage it. In the UK, CMI and YouGov found that 82% of managers who enter management positions have had no formal management and leadership training. CMI calls them accidental managers.
That gap matters because managers carry the weight. Gallup’s research shows managers account for at least 70% of the variance in employee engagement scores. The managers themselves are running low too. Gallup’s 2026 State of the Global Workplace found manager engagement fell from 27% to 22% in 2025, a nine-point drop since 2022.
A promoted top performer usually defaults to one mode: pacesetting. Set a punishing bar, model it personally and expect everyone to keep up. It feels like high standards. In Goleman’s data it did more damage to climate than any style except commanding, because the standard lives in the manager’s head. People stop understanding the why and start guessing what the boss wants. It’s the same pattern behind the manager gap: the best individual contributor gets a team and keeps doing what made them great.
Across your org, the pattern repeats. Each manager has one style and uses it on every person in every situation. The cost shows up in your engagement survey and your regretted attrition, and in the signs of a good manager you’re not hearing about in skip-level meetings.
What Are the Six Management Styles?
Treat the six styles as clubs in a bag. Each one does a particular job well, and Goleman’s team scored each one’s effect on climate. His 2000 article calls commanding “coercive” and visionary “authoritative.” His later work uses the newer names, so you’ll see those below.
1. Commanding: “Do what I tell you”
Commanding demands immediate compliance. Goleman’s data shows it has a place in a real crisis, in a turnaround, and with a problem employee when nothing else has worked. Think of a security breach or a legal emergency. Outside those moments, it had the most negative effect on climate of all six styles. People comply. Then they stop offering ideas.
2. Visionary: “Come with me”
The leader names where the team is going and why, then gives people room on the how. In Goleman’s research it had the strongest positive effect on climate of the six. It works because context travels: people can make good calls without asking first. New managers often skip it, because it means explaining strategy, and until now they’ve mostly been handed tasks.
3. Affiliative: “People come first”
Affiliative builds harmony and emotional bonds. It helps a team recover after layoffs or a failed launch. Used alone, it lets poor performance go uncorrected, because hard feedback threatens the harmony the style exists to protect. Goleman suggests pairing it with visionary.
Our own data shows how common this is. Across the 78 assessments in our Team Dynamics Assessment database, “My supervisor seems to care about me as a person” often scores above 4.6 out of 5, one of the highest items we measure. “Team members hold each other accountable” scores significantly lower. We call it the Benevolent Leader Paradox: managers care deeply and shield their teams from pressure, so the standards rest on the manager alone. If a team scores above 4.0 on psychological safety and below 3.5 on accountability, it’s stuck in a comfort zone. The fix is to raise standards while keeping the safety.

4. Democratic: “What do you think?”
Democratic builds buy-in through participation. Goleman found a positive effect on climate, with two catches: it eats time, and it flops when the team lacks the context to weigh in. Use it when commitment matters more than speed, like setting team norms or changing a process. Skip it in a crisis, and watch for managers who call a meeting to avoid making a call.
5. Pacesetting: “Do as I do, now”
Pacesetting means high standards, modelled personally. It works for short stretches with a senior, self-motivated team that needs little direction. Applied broadly, it hurt climate almost as much as commanding in Goleman’s data. People feel overwhelmed, and the work turns into guessing the standard. It’s the natural default for a promoted top performer, because it’s how they earned the promotion.
6. Coaching: “Try this”
Coaching develops people for the long term by connecting their growth to their work. Goleman found a clear positive effect on climate and reported it as the style leaders used least often. Leaders told the researchers they didn’t have time for the slow work of teaching people. That gets it backwards. Coaching is what creates the time, because it builds people who don’t need you for every decision.
Which Management Style Works Best for a Scale-Up?
No single style. Goleman found that leaders who had mastered four or more, especially visionary, democratic, affiliative and coaching, had the best climate and the best business performance. Effectiveness tracks range.
If you want a priority order for a scale-up, use this one.
- Make visionary the default. Growth means constant change, and change without context breeds fear. A manager who repeats where the team is going and why, every week, is doing the most valuable work available to them.
- Make coaching the growth engine. You can’t hire your way out of a leadership gap at scale-up speed. You have to grow managers internally. In the Six Levels of High-Performing Teams, that’s Level 4, Culture of Leadership, where a manager’s job is to grow more leaders.
- Treat pacesetting and commanding as emergency tools. Use them for a week or two, then switch back. A manager who has been in pacesetting mode for six months has stalled.
One more finding for your exec team. In his 1998 article “What Makes a Leader?”, Goleman found emotional intelligence was twice as important as technical skill and IQ for excellent performance in jobs at all levels. Switching styles is an emotional intelligence skill, which is why our guide to emotional intelligence for managers pairs with this one.
How Do You Build Style Range Across Your Manager Layer?
Knowing the six styles is the easy part. Range comes from practice, and you can start this four-step rollout this month.
Step 1: Name each manager’s default
Run a self-audit in your next manager meeting. Ask each manager to think of their last five tricky moments with a direct report and name the style they used each time. Many will find one style covers most of the five. That default is the starting point. A manager can’t choose a style until they can see the one they fall back on.
A DISC assessment speeds this up, because style defaults tend to follow personality. High-D managers tend to drift toward commanding and pacesetting. High-S managers tend to drift toward affiliative and put off hard calls. Spotting the pattern early lets a manager catch it before it costs them a team member.
Step 2: Match the style to the person
The Golden Rule says to treat people the way you want to be treated. The Platinum Rule, which we teach alongside DISC, says to treat them the way they want to be treated. In our leadership course, we put it this way: how much you care is measured at the other person’s ear, not by how you meant it. A first-week hire needs direction. A senior engineer needs coaching and room. A team in a crisis needs command, briefly, followed by an explanation.
Give managers a one-line diagnostic: “What does this person need from me right now: direction, context, care, a vote, a bar or a question?” Six needs, six styles. It fits on a sticky note.
Our playbook for managing each DISC style goes deeper on what each personality needs from a manager.
Step 3: Practise the unnatural style on purpose
Range comes from reps. Have each manager pick their weakest style and use it on purpose once a week, in a low-stakes moment. The pacesetter asks a coaching question and stays quiet for ten seconds. The affiliative manager gives one piece of direct feedback before Friday.
That’s what good manager development trains: supervised practice with feedback, on real situations. For senior leaders whose defaults have hardened, one-on-one executive coaching does the same work with higher stakes.
Step 4: Measure climate by manager
You already run engagement surveys. Add two statements per team. “I understand why my work matters to the company’s goals” tests visionary, and “My manager helps me grow” tests coaching. Track them by manager, share the results with the managers themselves, and look for the missing styles wherever scores sag.
Break the results out manager by manager, because team averages hide the story. In our Team Dynamics Assessment data, Effective Communication scores range from 2.75 to 4.58 between teams, the widest spread of any level, which suggests it depends on what individual leaders do. A Team Dynamics Assessment shows where each team stands across all six levels. If you need to defend the spend, our post on making the case for leadership development to a CFO has the numbers.
One Club in the Bag
Back to your engineer-turned-manager. She’s been playing every hole with one club, and half her team needs a different one. That’s fixable, and her next one-on-one is a good place to start. Before she walks in, she asks herself the sticky-note question: what does this person need from me right now? Then she picks the club.
Building out your manager development plan? Book a strategy call and we’ll walk through how to build style range in your managers. Want them rehearsing before the hard conversations? The Practice Lab lets managers practise tough feedback and conflict conversations with AI personas that react like real people.
Frequently Asked Questions:
Now that you have mastered how to manage conflict - what is your plan of action for making an impact with your team?
Now that you have mastered how to create an environment of empowerment via the 3-P's - what is your plan of action for making an impact with your team?
Developing Your Communication, Empathy and Emotional Intelligence skills is start. What is your plan of action for implementing your learnings within your your team?
Now that you understand the differences in these titles - what is your plan of action for what you learned?
Assessing your team's behaviors is a start - but do you have a plan of action for the results?
Now that you have mastered the art of decision making - what is your plan of action for making an impact with your team?
.png)
A DISC Behaviour Assessment is the best way to understand your team's personalities.
Each DISC Assessment includes a Self Assessment and DISC Style evaluation worksheet


.webp)

