Leadership

A Practical Guide Scenario Planning for Startups: A 90-Minute Method for Your Next Offsite

Table of Contents:

In 2015, Uber Eats launched in Toronto. By that summer, Uber was worth about $51 billion. For SkipTheDishes, a food delivery startup from the Prairies, that was the giant every founder dreads, aimed straight at their market. Cofounder Jeff Adamson has said that when it happened, he thought it was over.

Most founders react to news like that in one of two ways. They panic and rip up the plan, or they shrug and hope the storm misses them. Scenario planning for startups is the third option: your leadership team maps the few futures you might face, prices each one, and agrees in advance what you’ll do in each. When the scary news lands, you run a play you already wrote.

You don’t need a strategy department to do it. You need 90 minutes with your exec team, usually inside a strategy offsite, and a method simple enough to survive your calendar. This guide gives you that method.

‍

Why Do Startup Forecasts Break?

Your financial model has one future in it. Reality has dozens.

Big companies can absorb a bad year. You can’t. One wrong assumption about churn, the fundraising market or a competitor’s launch can burn six months of runway. Forecasting harder doesn’t fix it, because a forecast is a bet that tomorrow looks like yesterday, and startups live exactly where it doesn’t.

Scenario planning doesn’t try to predict better. It gets you ready to decide faster once the future shows which way it’s going.

Forecasting vs scenario planning

What you're comparingForecastingScenario planning
The question it answersWhat will happen?What will we do if?
How many futuresOneFour, priced as base, bear and bull cases
Built fromPast data and trendsOutside forces you can't control
Breaks whenThe future stops looking like the pastNobody rereads it or checks the tripwires
What you walk away withA budget and a hiring planA play ready for each future, with an owner
Best forRunning this quarterDeciding fast when the world changes

Startups need both. Early-stage data is too thin to trust a single forecast, so the scenarios carry more of the weight.

There’s evidence that this kind of readiness pays. Researchers René Rohrbeck and Menes Kum measured how prepared 83 large companies were for future change in 2008, then looked at their results in 2015. The best-prepared firms had 33% higher profitability than the average company in the study, and 200% higher growth in market value. The study measured future-readiness in general, and scenario planning is one way to build it.

The real payoff is speed. When something breaks, a team that has done this work asks “which play is this?” Everyone else books an emergency meeting.

‍

How Do You Run Scenario Planning in 90 Minutes?

Forget the six-week corporate version with consultants and binders. This is a 90-minute version built for Series A and B leadership teams, and it fits inside a quarterly offsite.

The 90-minute agenda

90 minutes in total

  1. Starts at 0:00

    Name two uncertainties

    Outside forces with high impact that you can't control.

    15 min
  2. Starts at 0:15

    Build four futures

    A 2x2 with one uncertainty on each axis, and a name for every quadrant.

    20 min
  3. Starts at 0:35

    Write the money version

    Base, bear and bull cases: revenue, burn, runway and headcount.

    20 min
  4. Starts at 0:55

    Set tripwires

    A signal and a response, agreed while everyone is calm.

    Protect this one

    20 min
  5. Starts at 1:15

    Assign the first move

    One owner and one page for the first 30 days of each scenario.

    15 min

Step 4 is the one that gets cut when time runs short, and it's the one you need most. Protect those 20 minutes.

‍

Step 1: Name Your Two Biggest Uncertainties (15 Minutes)

Ask the room: what are the two outside forces that could change our year the most, that we can’t control? Common answers are the fundraising market, a giant entering your category, a platform changing its rules, and enterprise sales cycles doubling.

Pick two. Every other force is noise you can handle as it comes. Choose forces with high impact and real uncertainty. If everyone already agrees what will happen, it belongs in the forecast.

‍

Step 2: Build the Four Futures (20 Minutes)

Draw a 2x2 with one uncertainty on each axis. You now have four plausible worlds. Give each one a name your team will remember, like Frozen Capital, Hot Competitor or Open Wallets, Empty Field.

Example: the four futures

Two uncertainties, one on each axis. Here, the fundraising market and whether a big competitor enters your category.

Bear case

Frozen Capital, Hot Competitor

Money is hard to raise and a rival is spending to win your customers. Runway comes first.

Base case

Open Wallets, Hot Competitor

Capital is there, and so is a fight. Speed and focus decide who wins.

Base case

Frozen Capital, Empty Field

Hard to raise, but the market is yours if you can stretch the cash.

Bull case

Open Wallets, Empty Field

The best case. Decide in advance where extra money would go first.

Use your own two uncertainties. The worst quadrant becomes your bear case, the best becomes your bull case, and the two in the middle share the base case.

Names matter more than they should. Six months from now, someone will say “this looks like Frozen Capital” in a Monday meeting, and the whole team will picture the same thing. That shared picture is rarer than most founders think. In our Team Dynamics Assessment benchmark, built from 78 assessments and more than 900 people, All-Encompassing Vision is the lowest-scoring of the six levels of high-performing teams, at 3.69 out of 5. Teams work hard without a clear view of where they’re headed. A named scenario gives them one.

‍

Step 3: Write the Money Version (20 Minutes)

Now turn the futures into three financial cases. Your worst quadrant becomes the bear case, your best becomes the bull case, and the two middle quadrants usually share the base case. For each case, write down four numbers: the revenue range, monthly burn, runway in months, and the headcount you can carry.

Keep it to one page. The bear case is the one founders skip, and it’s the one that saves you. If your bear case shows nine months of runway, you want to know that today, while you still have options.

The runway check

Swap the example values for your own. Net burn is what you spend each month minus what comes in.

Include money you've raised but not spent.
Base case0 monthsof runway
Bear case0 monthsof runway
Bull case0 monthsof runway

Runway is rounded down to whole months, and the bars fill at 36 months. Nothing you enter is saved or sent anywhere.

‍

Step 4: Set Tripwires (20 Minutes)

This is the step that turns scenario planning from a discussion into a decision. A tripwire is a signal you agree on now, plus the response you agree on now. If churn crosses 4% for two months in a row, we freeze hiring. If the round doesn’t have a term sheet by March 1, we cut burn by 20%.

Set the triggers while you’re calm. Neuroscientist Amy Arnsten’s research on stress and the brain shows that even mild stress you can’t control quickly weakens the prefrontal cortex, the part of the brain we use for planning and judgment. That’s the state you’ll be in when the bad news arrives. Tripwires move the hard thinking to a day when you can still think. Our guide to executive decision-making covers the broader skill.

Build your tripwires

A tripwire is a signal plus a response, agreed before you need it. Start from an example or write your own.

My tripwires

Nothing added yet. Start with three to five.

    Nothing you type is saved or sent anywhere. Copy your list before you leave the page.

    ‍

    Step 5: Assign the First Move (15 Minutes)

    For each scenario, one owner writes the first 30 days: what we cut, what we double down on, and who tells whom. One page each.

    Then pressure-test the whole plan with a premortem. Assume it’s a year from now and the plan failed, and have the team explain why. It’s a cheap way to surface the assumptions nobody wanted to question.

    Row of white Unicorn Labs branded coffee mugs lined up on a wooden table with drawstring welcome bags behind them at a leadership event

    ‍

    What Happens When One of Your Scenarios Arrives?

    Back to SkipTheDishes. Skip couldn’t outspend Uber. What it had was a market it already knew. The company started in mid-size cities like Red Deer and Grande Prairie, and it kept building there while Uber Eats started in Toronto. In December 2016, Just Eat bought Skip, which gave it the backing of one of the world’s biggest delivery companies.

    Look at the order of events, though. Adamson thought it was over first. The play came after the shock. Skip found the right move under pressure. Scenario planning lets you find yours before the pressure arrives.

    Acting early looks like this. When COVID shut down live sports in 2020, the sports-data startup StellarAlgo had customers with no games to sell. Early on, the company let go of five people, 16% of its team, and offered customers who needed it a three-month payment deferral. Dan Fergusson, its senior VP of sales and marketing, told BetaKit the company was “trying to be honest and trying to right-size before all sports shut down.” They moved on the signal instead of waiting for certainty. Tripwires let you do the same thing on purpose.

    ‍

    How Do You Prepare Your Team for the Session?

    You could run this on a Monday, but it lands better with the full leadership team in the room and some homework done in advance. A week before, send out three things:

    • Two questions for each leader. Which outside force worries you most this year, and what number would tell us it’s arriving? Ask for written answers, sent to whoever is running the session. Written pre-work brings out disagreements that polite meetings hide.
    • A request to whoever owns the financial model. Bring this quarter’s cash, monthly burn and pipeline, so Step 3 runs on real numbers.
    • A 90-minute calendar block nobody can shorten to 60. Step 4 is the one that gets cut when time runs short, and it’s the one you need most.

    If you’re planning a bigger reset, fold this session into a 2-day strategy offsite and give it the second day, after the team has agreed on where things stand. It also fits naturally into your annual planning and your broader strategic planning process.

    One warning: don’t let the founder run this session. You’ll anchor everyone to your favourite future. Have someone else hold the marker, and spend your energy arguing the scenarios.

    ‍

    Name Your Futures Before They Arrive

    Nobody at SkipTheDishes knew when Uber Eats would show up. You won’t know when your version arrives either, and your plan will still be wrong somewhere. But a team that has named its futures, priced its bear case and set its tripwires can respond in days, while others spend a quarter arguing.

    Start this week. Put the two-uncertainties question on the agenda for your next leadership meeting, and ask each leader to answer it in writing first.

    Want help running the full session? Book a strategy call and we’ll help you design it for your exec team. And if every scenario still routes through you, start with the Founder Operating System or our guide to the founder bottleneck.

    Run it with your exec team

    Get your futures named before the next surprise

    We'll help you design the 90 minutes for your leadership team, from the two uncertainties to the tripwires. If every scenario still routes through you, start with the Founder Operating System.

    ‍

    Frequently Asked Questions:

    A planning method where your leadership team maps a few plausible futures, prices each one, and agrees in advance how you'll respond, before events force the choice. A simple version fits in 90 minutes: two uncertainties, four named futures, three money cases (base, bear and bull), and tripwires with owners.

    A forecast projects one expected future from past data. Scenario planning assumes the future is uncertain and prepares for several versions of it. Forecasts answer "what will happen?" Scenarios answer "what will we do if?" Startups need both, but scenarios matter more early on, because early-stage data is too thin to trust any single forecast.

    Four futures and three money cases. Two uncertainties on a 2x2 give you four futures, enough to cover the real range and few enough that people remember them. Then price them as a base, bear and bull case, each with revenue, burn, runway and headcount on one page. Give the bear case the most attention, because it tells you when you must act.

    Check your tripwires monthly, rebuild your scenarios each quarter, and redo the full exercise once a year or after any major shock. A quarterly rebuild keeps the scenarios close enough to reality that people still trust them. A scenario document nobody rereads is just paperwork. The monthly 10-minute tripwire check keeps it working.

    The exec team, plus whoever owns the financial model. Keep it under eight people so the debate stays honest. Have someone other than the founder run the session, because founder-run rooms tend to settle on the founder's favourite future. Written pre-work from each leader brings out disagreements that polite meetings hide.

    ‍

    Now that you have mastered how to manage conflict - what is your plan of action for making an impact with your team?

    Now that you have mastered how to create an environment of empowerment via the 3-P's - what is your plan of action for making an impact with your team?

    Developing Your Communication, Empathy and Emotional Intelligence skills is start. What is your plan of action for implementing your learnings within your your team?

    Now that you understand the differences in these titles - what is your plan of action for what you learned?

    Assessing your team's behaviors is a start - but do you have a plan of action for the results?

    Now that you have mastered the art of decision making - what is your plan of action for making an impact with your team?

    Download your free leadership guide that outlines the 6 necessary steps you need to acheive in order to develop a high performing team (in weeks, not months).  
    Download your free leadership guide that outlines the 6 necessary steps you need to acheive in order to develop a high performing team (in weeks, not months).  
    Download your free leadership guide that outlines the 6 necessary steps you need to acheive in order to develop a high performing team (in weeks, not months).  
    Download your free leadership guide that outlines the 6 necessary steps you need to acheive in order to develop a high performing team (in weeks, not months).  
    Help your managers improve their managing of communication, collaboration and conflict. Download your free leadership guide that outlines the 6 necessary steps you need to achieve in order to develop a high performing team (in weeks, not months).
    Download your free leadership guide that outlines the 6 necessary steps you need to acheive in order to develop a high performing team (in weeks, not months).  
    Get My Free Leadership Guide Now

    A DISC Behaviour Assessment is the best way to understand your team's personalities.

    Start by understanding your own behaviour tendencies with a DISC assessment. Learn more about how a DISC Assessment will improve your potential as a leader!

    Each DISC Assessment includes a Self Assessment and DISC Style evaluation worksheet
    Bill Gates Training Sidebar
    Bill Gates Leadership

    Curious how to develop into a transformational leader like Bill Gates?

    Start by accessing our FREE Training video that outlines six simple steps for creating an environment that will transform YOU, and YOUR TEAM, into Unicorn leaders.

    Leadership Training Ad - Sidebar
    Leadership Training

    Are you ready to transform from just a manager into a Unicorn Leader?

    You can access our FREE training that will give you clarity on how to create a successful team in just six steps.

    Leadership Training Ad - Sidebar
    Leadership Training

    Curious on some tips for transforming your managers into leaders?

    Access our BEST, free training video that HR leaders are using to inspire real conversations with their managers.

    In less than 25 minutes, you can gain clarity on how to turn your teams into centers for growth.

    Access FREE Leadership Training Now
    Career Conversations Sidebar
    Career Conversations Guide

    Is Your Company Culture Stuck In A Rut? Sometimes creating an environment for continuous learning can make a huge difference.

    We created the best guide for having career development conversations with your teams.

    Increase motivation and retain your top talent by following these simple steps.

    EQ Leadership Sidebar
    EQ Leadership Image

    Did you know that EQ is more valuable to a leader than IQ?

    We created the BEST, FREE training video to help managers map out a clear path for transformation into a Unicorn Leader.

    Are you ready for your leadership transformation?

    Access FREE Leadership Training Now
    Leadership Workshop Sidebar
    Leadership Workshop Image

    Empowering your team to make decisions is just the start. Are you also supporting the other key elements for a high-performing team?

    An investment in your team's development is an investment in your company's ability to effectively scale.

    We've created an experiential, virtual workshop that focuses on developing teams into scalable engines of growth.

    Interested in customizing a workshop for your team?

    Learn More About The Leadership Workshop

    Related posts